Monday, 1 July 2013
Are the unions really taking over the labour party?
Sounds a strange thing to say given it was the trade unions who came together to set up the original labour party notably a far cry from the party it is today I’d remind any labour left trying to claim the unions should still back labour I’d dispute this strongly. But in the last month and a bit there has been an interesting development in Falkirk West. New Labour has suspended its parliamentary selection process in Scottish constituency Falkirk West for the byelection to replace disgraced MP Eric Joyce. An investigation into alleged 'irregularities' is being organised by party officials. This follows allegations against Unite the Union of recruiting members to the constituency. Unite has the aim of getting more working class candidates selected and elected as MPs and councillors. For Falkirk West, Unite member Karie Murphy was touted as a candidate. While Murphy's record is open to criticism, Unite should have a say in the selection process. Unite is New Labour's biggest affiliate, paying over £3 million a year in affiliation fees. Its political strategy is to try and transform New Labour back to its roots and strengthen party democracy. The Socialist party has always said that, for this strategy to stand any chance, Unite would have to go into New Labour with a full programme against all cuts and privatisation, and for socialist economic policies. It would be no good replacing Blairite right wingers with trade union backed ones. Expulsions However, the limits to this strategy have become apparent. A handful of Labour councillors, largely Unite members and including the two brave Southampton councillors, have voted against cuts and found themselves suspended or expelled from Labour groups. Right-wing leaders, locally and nationally, do not tolerate challenges to the pro-capitalist policies of New Labour. Many years ago now, the Labour right wing brought in the 'one member one vote' (OMOV) selection processes for parliamentary candidates, replacing selection by the constituency parties' general committees (GC). This was because the right believed the GCs were dominated by the left and trade union delegates, so OMOV would make the selection of right-wing candidates more likely. The right wanted a party that was safe for big business. Of course, the right have always feared a mass membership party that was based on fighting for socialist policies. They feared the influence of socialist and Marxist ideas in the 1970s and 1980s. They launched an offensive against the Socialist's predecessor, Militant, which led to expulsions from Labour, including of two Marxist MPs, Terry Fields and Dave Nellist. This was with the ambition of neutering Labour's fighting wing. Militant warned that this would lead to the defeat of the whole left in Labour. The right allowed moribund parties to develop. What attraction was there for the failed policies of Labour governments? Where socialists ran local parties, mass membership campaigns were launched. There was something for working class people to join and fight alongside. And it was electorally popular too, as the success of the Liverpool council between 1983 and 1987 proved. The irony now is that Unite has recruited to Labour in Falkirk West, and the Labour officials and Blairites are up in arms! The same arguments that were used against Militant 30 years ago are now deployed against the biggest trade union in the country! The outcome of Falkirk West is unclear but the conclusions for trade unionists are not. New Labour will protect its right-wing policies against the organised working class. Trade unions will have to come to the conclusion that Labour is no longer the party it formed in 1900 and that a genuine mass working class party has to be built. Lambeth councillor Kingsley Abrams has lost his appeal to rejoin the Labour group in the borough. Kingsley was originally suspended for abstaining in the council in 2010 on a vote to implement cuts. Since then, he has continued to oppose cuts with the backing of his trade union, Unite, of which he is an executive council member. Continued suspension will mean he will be ineligible to stand for reselection as a Labour candidate for the 2014 borough elections. Local supporters and Unite activists will no doubt be considering the options that Kingsley could take as part of an anti-cuts platform in Lambeth. To me this is more evidence of unites bankrupt strategy of funding labour to the hilt undemocratically I might add as the membership are not allowed a say on what the unions political fund is spent on. Clearly trying to reclaim the labour party is a dead end strategy with unite alone trying its hand here and there Falkirk has been the only place where they have any sort of success and now the right wing are kicking back already so can you imagine if the union launched a full scale recruitment drive to the party. Which they have already tried with the aim of recruiting 5000 to the labour party yet only a tiny figure around 600 have joined and even those will soon find out like I did how undemocratic and how anti worker the party is today. What unite and other trade unions who still to this day fund this rotten capitalist party and back anti cuts candidates opening the political fund up to a democratic process giving members a say what they’d like their membership subs to fund. Len and others in unite will be in for a long bloody battle if they carry on with this strategy there will be a big battle between labour and unite if labour do regain power in 2015 and carry on making the cuts which they are sure to do this will force unite to fight back with their membership moving to the left for sure and with labour moving further to the right if that was possible will only further tensions between the two. With thanks to socialist party comrade Kevin Parslow, Unite 1/1228 branch secretary (personal capacity)